Interview on Ethical Dilemma
Interview on Ethical Dilemma
Interview summary with Hospital Administrator –Shirley
1- Please describe your philosophy and views on the national right-to-die battle of Terry Schiavo?
Shirley, the hospital administrator, indicated that the national right to die categorically displays the conditions that one can ask to die. One requires no control over their lives especially in situations like that of Terri. Terri was in pain and to make it worse she was not able to communicate (Khan, 2006).
Shirley agreed that United States Congress intervention was appropriate. Shirley indicated that the attention the case got would be good for the public to understand their rights.
3- In your opinion, do you think Mr. Schiavo or Mr. & Mrs. Schindler should have had the authority in making the final decision in Terry’s case as to whether or not to withdrawal the feeding tube?
Given the gravity of the matter, Shirley notes that those close to Terri had right to make decisions for her. Terri was using an artificial tube for many months. Her husband pointed out that Terri would not have liked it to be supported artificially.
4- What is your worldview on the ethical issues surrounding euthanasia?
Shirley during the interview noted that she believed euthanasia should only be used when pain and agony experienced by the patient cannot be controlled. She indicated that life is important, and it should be respected.
Interview Summary of the Spiritual Leader – Barbara
1- Please describe your philosophy and views on the national right-to-die battle of Terry Schiavo?
Barbara argued that the national right to die is not appropriate. Barbara believes in the notion that God is mocked when such laws are passed. He believes that respect for life must be exercised at all times (Khan, 2006). The spiritual leader cites the bible about respect for life Proverbs 24:11-12 “Rescue those who are being taken away to death; hold back those who are stumbling to the slaughter.”
Intervention by the United States Congress was ideal. However, Barbara disagrees with their motive in supporting the use removal of the tube. The intervention became a legal case since Terri could not speak for herself and the Congress saw it prudent to intervene.
3- In your opinion, do you think Mr. Schiavo or Mr. & Mrs. Schindler should have had the authority in making the final decision in Terry’s case as to whether or not to withdrawal the feeding tube?
Barbara does not concur with Mr. Schiavo's move in deciding for his wife. Barbara claims that even if Mrs. Schiavo was unable to communicate, no assumption should be made regarding her decision. The final decision only comes from God. God decides when to take his people. The feeding tube should not be withdrawn (Franklin Springs Family Media, 2009).
4- What is your worldview on the ethical issues surrounding euthanasia?
The essence of globalization has led to the innovation of appropriate pain relievers. Barbara pointed that euthanasia is not supported spiritually. Therefore, it should not be implemented.
Summary Interview with Health Care Colleague – Jonatha
1- Please describe your philosophy and views on the national right-to-die battle of Terry Schiavo?
Jonatha version concerning National right to die concerning Terry points at the human rights policies. Jonatha cites the medical ethics that prevents health care officers interfering with patient’s decisions (Khan, 2006).
Jonatha believes that the intervention was not appropriate. The scenario brought the health care sector into unnecessary public scrutiny. It even led to the court intervention concerning the case.
3- In your opinion, do you think Mr. Schiavo or Mr. & Mrs. Schindler should have had the authority in making the final decision in Terry’s case as to whether or not to withdraw the feeding tube?
Jonatha opinion supports Mr. Shiavo's move to decide for his wife. Although the patient receives the final decision, the challenge was that Terri was paralyzed and could not communicate.
4- What is your worldview on the ethical issues surrounding euthanasia?
Ethically, Jonatha believed that euthanasia application should be only be reserved for medical reasons. His worldview denotes that consent must be sought from the patient on the application of the procedure.
Interview summary with Neighbor/Friend – (Chinyere- Interviewer)
1- Please describe your philosophy and views on the national right-to-die battle of Terry Schiavo?
His philosophical view is based on the assertion that life is sacred, and everyone is entitled to manage theirs. The policy should be a guidelines in dealing with voluntary deaths. Terri Shiavo battle required the intervention of the state. The neighbor believes that the right to live must be accorded to everyone. Pulling the tube voluntary is like killing the patient without her consent.
The intervention by the United States Congress was significant. He points at the additional information that the public was able to grasp hence more informed about the right to die battle. It was a concern since the directives of the patient were not documented earlier hence her wishes could not be known.3- In your opinion, do you think Mr. Schiavo or Mr. & Mrs. Schindler should have had the authority in making the final decision in Terry’s case as to whether or not to withdrawal the feeding tube?
Both parties had the right to decide for Terri. Further, the neighbor claims that the law allows the guidelines that a family member signs for the patients were the patient is paralyzed, and his or her decision cannot be retrieved (Franklin Springs Family Media, 2009).
4- What is your worldview on the ethical issues surrounding euthanasia?
Neighbor’s opinion is based on the usefulness of euthanasia in supporting the end of pain. However, he notes that life of a person should be respected, and natural death should only be supported. Otherwise, the health personnel should ensure they do everything they can to save lives. It is paramount to utilize the modern medicine to sustain lives and help those who are gravely sick.
References
Franklin Springs Family Media. (2009). The Terri Schiavo Story. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cki55BM42kw
Khan, F. A. (2006). The Right to Die: Some Personal Reflections on the Terri Schiavo Case and the Role of Hydration and Nutrition in Hopelessly Ill Patients. J Islam Med Assoc, 38(1). doi:10.5915/38-1-6304
