Introduction
Argument analysis essay discusses arguments from a variety of perspectives. A general argument is made of a claim and a rationale (Lamm & Everett, 2007). This paper explores many elements of the authors’ arguments which include the strength of thesis, support of thesis as well as weaknesses in the arguments. The paper relies on the arguments in chapter four, five and seventeen throughout its development.
Are arguments strong?
In chapter seventeen, the writer introduces his audience to the central issue of security in the United States of America. The essay titled Islam and the West examines the security situation in the US and claims that the life in America is insecure now compared to the years of the past. In chapter four, the writer makes strong arguments regarding the response of the readers to arguments. The character in the essay has the ability to think critically and analyse facts that go beyond the surface. In this introduction, the writer underscores the essential feature of a good argument. Some of the arguments presented do not sufficiently give a strong position on the issues they represent. However, Islam and the West gives a strong position on the subject of security.
Do they prove thesis statement?
The argument on security in the United States has clearly proven thesis statement. The writer has highlighted some of the reasons why US citizens feel insecure. Although these factors existed even much earlier, the fact that they have increased with time lends credence to the thesis. In chapter five, the writer recognizes the difficulty of finishing a long and arduous journey. However, he observes that the task can be accomplished through manageable steps. The argument fails to provide sufficient support for its thesis.
Weaknesses which essay is stronger?
The essay on security in the US makes a strong argument based on the construction of claim and the supporting evidence. The writer observes that insecurity in the United States took a new turn after September 11 terrorist attack. The weakness in this argument is the assumption that all citizens on the United States experience similar security problems.
These essays have used evidence to support the various claims they represent. For example, the writer of the security essay argues that a US economy has sputtered over the years while the global environment has been endangered through unsustainable human practices. He lists other challenges which include high costs of energy, healthcare problems, porous border that makes it easy for immigrants to arrive at the United States. He argues that these immigrants compete for labour in the US, making the country unable to inspire a future of promise. The second argument does not utilize evidence throughout its development.
Principles or organization
These arguments are organized into claim, evidence and logic, and assumptions. In the claim, the writer makes a strong position on an issue. For example, Islam and the West argument creates a powerful position regarding the state of security in the United States. The writer then uses evidence to justify his position. Any argument utilizes evidence and logic to reinforce their claim (Lamm & Everett, 2007). In this regard, evidence serve as a basic pillar of most arguments. The arguments rely on assumptions because the claim they represent are dependent on certain conditions.
Conclusion
Reference
Lamm, R. L., & Everett, J. (2007). Dynamic Argument. Houghton Mifflin Company. Print.
