Introduction
Ideally the investigating officer clearly violated the Brady Rule. The officer would instead have had relied on the fourth witness, a situation that would provide more and reliable information regarding the suspect. It will be realized any information obtained from witnesses provided that they are mentally fit and unbiased should actually be relied on since people may have differing views concerning an event.
Studies extend to reveal that the Brady Rule requires all prosecutors to reveal materially exculpatory evidence within the possession of the government to the defense. Generally, the evidence that the prosecutor is actually required to reveal with respect to this rule embraces any evidence auspicious to the accused more precisely, an evidence that may truly go towards disproving the guilty of the defendant or that would probably lessen the potential sentence of the defendant or even an evidence that goes towards the trustworthiness of a witness (Brady Rule, n.d.). This essentially shows that the decision of the investigating officer violated this rule.
The robbery suspect description provided by the forth witness basically ought not to be assumed that it might confuse the matter since it can help in negating the guiltiness of the suspect or probably assist in decreasing the potential verdict of the defendant. On the other hand, the witnesses’ evidence may perhaps be not in favor of the suspect and hence help in providing reliable evidence towards the guiltiness of the defendant, a condition that helps in obtaining the decision of the court. Differing evidences automatically reveal that the decision made by the court is unbiased and free from any favoritism and therefore should be relied on.
This clearly implies that the investigating officer should not have declined the statement from the fourth witness as it would have been dependable from a critical evaluation of the law professionals.
References
Brady Rule. (n. d.). LII / Legal Information Institute. Retrieved from http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/brady_rule.
