Levin describes a scenario in which he claims torture is morally obligatory (mandatory). Recall that he puts his foot in his mouth in 3 different ways. That is, he makes 3 mistakes in describing this scenario (the terrorist has hidden a nuclear bomb in NYC). Given these mistakes, it does not follow it is morally obligatory to torture the terrorist. HOW WOULD YOU FIX THESE 3 MISTAKES?
1. Torture won’t work out if a terrorist prefers death to failure. 2. One can not distinguish certain pain intensity as “the most excruciating possible pain”. 3. Levin’s statement that torture ...